Critical Minerals and Energy Intelligence

The ESG illusion: why investors want impact, not paperwork (Guest post by Jamie Strauss)

Subscribe for Investment Insights. Stay Ahead.

Investment market and industry insights delivered to you in real-time.

Jamie Strauss is the Founder and CEO of Digbee, the leading sustainability disclosure and assurance platform built specifically for the mining sector. Under his leadership, Digbee has become widely acknowledged by Tier 1 capital providers as the industry’s trusted solution for credible, asset-level sustainability performance. Jamie is also a Director of Altius Minerals and a Trustee of the Julian Baring Scholarship Fund.

A successful entrepreneur, Jamie previously founded and led a mining finance boutique, which he built into a market leader before selling it to BMO Capital Markets. His career reflects a deep commitment to enhancing transparency, responsibility, and performance in the global mining industry.

Let’s be honest: ESG has become a loaded term. For many, it’s synonymous with bureaucracy, endless paperwork, and a detached compliance exercise. But that’s not what investors want. They want impact — real, measurable risk mitigation and responsible growth that enhances long-term value. It’s time we stop hiding behind the acronym and start talking about what really matters: de-risking, responsible development, and operational excellence.

From ESG to real strategy

The mining sector stands at a pivotal crossroads. Over the past decade, ESG reporting has exploded—policies, frameworks, and glossy PDFs abound. Yet for all the noise, how much of this is truly helping companies operate more responsibly or attract more capital?

There’s a world of difference between value-adding sustainability actions and the tick-box compliance culture ESG has too often become. The former protects social license, gets projects through permitting, and ensures smoother due diligence. It provides a tangible tool for boards and management to make informed, strategic decisions. The latter clutters the landscape with irrelevant metrics, opaque ratings, and cynical “green” slides buried in corporate presentations. Investors see through it—and they’re tired of it.

ESG is dead. Long live responsible investing

The so-called “death of ESG” is not a retreat from responsibility—it’s a reset.

Capital is flowing away from labels and into businesses that can prove they are prepared, agile, and trustworthy. This is where mining has an extraordinary opportunity to rebrand and reposition.

The fundamentals of mining haven’t changed: we operate in remote locations, manage sensitive relationships, and are judged by how we handle complexity under pressure. What’s changed is that capital markets now reward companies that bake sustainability into strategy—not those that bolt it on after the fact.

But it’s not just investors. Offtakers are demanding greater supply chain resilience, wary of sourcing disruptions caused by social or environmental blowback. M&A teams are increasingly cautious—wary of acquiring permitting risk, social opposition, or underreported liabilities. Lenders are tightening terms where projects lack a credible sustainability footing.

The winners will be those who embrace this shift. The losers? Companies that treat sustainability as a PR afterthought will find themselves increasingly isolated: higher cost of finance, diminished trust, and a shrinking pool of willing investors and partners.

Capital is watching

Investors, particularly institutional and project finance providers, are increasingly driven by risk-adjusted returns. They don’t want to be caught off guard by a social conflict, community protest, or governance scandal that derails a project. They want to know you’re ready—that the business is resilient, that stakeholder risks are mapped and mitigated, that climate and water strategies are integrated into cost and schedule planning.

In other words, capital wants comfort.

As Sylvain Eckert, a Partner at the French Government backed critical mineral fund managed by Infravia, explains “Sustainability is central to our investment mandate—not only because it reduces operational and reputational risk, but because it highlights management teams that are truly forward-thinking and capable of delivering long-term value.”

A shallow reference to sustainability buried in a corporate deck doesn’t cut it. It undermines the sector’s serious efforts to transform and fails to communicate the material impact of good sustainability on timelines, cost, and performance.

Discounted futures for the unprepared

For companies unwilling to evolve, the consequences will be stark. The cost of capital will rise. The trust deficit will grow. And the gap between responsible operators and the rest will widen. Worse, projects may never make it to production—blocked by permitting delays, social resistance, or the simple fact that no bank will touch them.

The market is already sorting the leaders from the laggards. Those who integrate sustainability into the core of their business are securing better financing, navigating regulatory hurdles more smoothly, and winning long term support from communities and investors alike.

This is just good business

Look at companies like Agnico Eagle or the Lundin family of companies—organisations that consistently underpromise, overdeliver, and demonstrate humility, preparation, and resilience. They don’t boast about ESG. They focus on doing the right things well, embedding sustainability in their strategy, and staying ready when issues inevitably arise. It’s not about virtue signalling. It’s about staying in business, on time, and on budget.

The bottom line? It’s time to move beyond ESG as an acronym and reframe the conversation. This isn’t about reporting. It’s about responsible growth, de-risking, and smart strategy. Investors are watching—and they’re ready to reward companies who take it seriously.

Because in the end, sustainability isn’t a cost. It’s a competitive advantage.

Subscribe for Investment Insights. Stay Ahead.

Investment market and industry insights delivered to you in real-time.

Disclaimer

The Oregon Group maintains full editorial control over all content published on this website. While sponsored and advertised placements may be featured, the content remains the sole opinion of The Oregon Group. The author may receive compensation or remuneration for providing content, but all statements and expressions are made independently and are not influenced by sponsors or advertisers. From time to time, The Oregon Group and its directors, officers, partners, employees, authors, or members of their families, as well as persons who are interviewed for articles on this website, may have a long or short position in securities or commodities mentioned and may make purchases and/or sales of those securities or commodities in the open market or otherwise. By accessing and using this website, readers are cautioned to assume that each of the foregoing persons may have a financial interest in all companies and sectors mentioned on this website. Any projections, market outlooks or estimates herein are forward looking statements and are inherently unreliable., and any such statements are based upon certain assumptions and should not be construed to be indicative of the actual events that will occur.  Other events that were not taken into account may occur and may significantly affect the returns or performance of the securities or commodities discussed herein. The information provided herein is based on matters as they exist as of the date of preparation and not as of any future date, and The Oregon Group undertakes no obligation to correct, update or revise the information in this document or to otherwise provide any additional material. The information provided on this website is for informational purposes only and is not, directly or indirectly, an offer, solicitation of an offer and/or a recommendation to buy or sell any security or commodity, and the information provided on this website should not be construed as any advice or an opinion as to the price at which the securities of any company or commodity may trade at any time. The Oregon Group is a publisher of financial information, not an investment advisor.  We do not provide personalized or individualized investment advice or information that is tailored to the needs of any particular recipient, and the information provided on this website is not and should not be construed as personal, financial, investment or professional advice. Readers are cautioned to always do their own research and review of publicly available information and to consult their professional and registered advisors before purchasing or selling any securities or commodities and should not rely on the information contained herein. Neither The Oregon Group nor any of its affiliates accepts any liability whatsoever for any direct or consequential loss howsoever arising, directly or indirectly, from any use of the information contained herein. By using the Site or any affiliated social media account, you are indicating your consent and agreement to this disclaimer and our terms of use. Unauthorized reproduction of this newsletter or its contents by photocopy, facsimile or any other means is illegal and punishable by law.

Share this article

about the author

Picture of The Oregon Group

The Oregon Group

The Oregon Group is an investment research team focused on critical minerals, mining, energy and geopolitics.

Our Podcast

Tags

Subscribe Now

Subscribe and get market and industry trends delivered to you in real-time.

SUBSCRIBE FOR INVESTMENT INSIGHTS

Welcome to The Oregon Group, an investment research team focused on critical minerals, mining, energy and geopolitics.

Our independent capital markets experts are sharing their boardroom expertise and institutional experience to help you profit and hedge your investment exposure during this time of unmissable opportunity.